Skip to main content
Faicco's Sausage

Italian Food in Greenwich Village, New York

Red and white pizzas anchor Italian food at The Pizza Box NY in Greenwich Village, New York, NY, with pickup available for your meal.

Order online

Pizza

Old School "NY Cheese"

$14.20

Shredded mozzarella and organic tomatoes cover 72-hour-fermented dough.

“Wow wow wow! Tried a free slice outside and it stopped me on my tracks. Went in for the old school NY cheese and honestly it hit the right notes in every way possible! Highly recommended!”

Margherita

$16.86

Tomato, Lioni mozzarella, basil, and olive oil top 72-hour-fermented dough.

“Words are hard to come by to accurately describe this establishment. Incredibly friendly staff and owners for a start. Menu is varied with lots of good pizza options. I had the asparagus and prosciutto and was not disappointed. If that’s not your style, their margherita is excellent. Ingredients are fresh, with home grown veggies and the dough is crisp and tasty. Atmosphere is fun and energetic. Definitely a must for any NYC dwellers or visitors!”

Pepperoni Honey

$16.86

Pepperoni pizza finished with Catskills fermented garlic honey.

“Came by after a corporate event and was warmly welcomed by the owners to one of the best pizzas I have ever had in NYC. Great location, beautiful restaurant ( bright with outdoor space), and absolutely delicious pies. My fav was the pepperoni with honey - all farm to table, locally sourced, fresh ingredients! Will definitely be coming back with the family to try them all!”

Classic Pepperoni

$15.97

Cup-and-char Ezzo pepperoni tops this old-school pizza.

“In such a pizza dense neighborhood it is almost crazy to get in the game, but this family run shop dared to go for it and nailed it. We were lucky enough to have tried their pizza way back from their first oven upstate, and now years later getting to see how far their mastery of pizza has come, I guess it only makes sense for them to thrive in the big league. The pepperoni and al pastor pies are killer.”

Gluten Free Food

Cannoli

Margherita

Find Something Special at The Pizza Box NY

The Pizza Box NY serves Italian food with red and white pizzas, including marinated pork with pineapple and white pies with pesto and squash. Beef and pork meatballs come with Lioni ricotta.

Margherita pairs fresh Lioni mozzarella with basil and EVOO. Classic Pepperoni features EZZO cup and char pepperoni, while Mushroom Pizza (White) combines mozzarella with roasted portobello mushrooms.

Visit us in Greenwich Village, New York, NY for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. GF Old School uses house-made dough for its 6-inch by 6-inch deep-dish format. Finish your meal with a large Cannoli.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular Italian food options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Old School "NY Cheese" — Organic Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes and shredded mozzarella top dough fermented for 72 hours in this New York-style cheese pizza.
  • Margherita — Bianco DiNapoli organic tomatoes and fresh Lioni mozzarella cover 72-hour-fermented dough, finished with basil and extra-virgin olive oil.
  • Pepperoni Honey — This pizza combines classic pepperoni with Catskills-fermented garlic honey; optional toppings include gluten-free Detroit-style dough and vegan cheese.
  • Classic Pepperoni — This old-school pizza is topped with Ezzo pepperoni, baked into curled cups with charred edges for a savory, crisp bite.
  • Faicco's Sausage — Shredded mozzarella and organic Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes accompany Faicco's sausage on this savory, meat-topped pizza.