Pizza in Greenwich Village, New York

Explore a creative pizza menu at The Pizza Box NY, serving Greenwich Village, New York, NY with convenient pickup options for every craving.

Order online

Popular Pizza to Try

Pepperoni Honey

$16.86

Pepperoni pizza finished with fermented garlic honey.

“A true Greenwich Village gem !!! I stumbled upon The Pizza Box while walking through the Village and was instantly charmed. The owner shared how many of their ingredients are sourced from farms upstate, and you can taste the difference—this might be some of the freshest, best-tasting pizza in all of New York. The atmosphere is casual yet thoughtfully decorated, with a cozy backyard seating area that feels like a hidden oasis. And you must try the locally sourced honey-pepperoni 12” pie—sweet, spicy, and absolutely delicious. A fantastic find. I’ll definitely be back !!! 🍕”

Old School "NY Cheese"

$14.20

Cheese pizza with mozzarella, organic tomatoes, and fermented dough.

“Wow wow wow! Tried a free slice outside and it stopped me on my tracks. Went in for the old school NY cheese and honestly it hit the right notes in every way possible! Highly recommended!”

Classic Pepperoni

$15.97

Classic pizza topped with EZZO cup-and-char pepperoni.

“This has quickly become my new favorite pizza spot. It’s a family-run place, with the son making the pizzas and the mom serving, and they’re incredibly kind and welcoming. You really feel at home here. I ordered the pepperoni pizza and it was so good, I’m still thinking about it! I will definitely be back!!!”

Meet The Pizza Box NY

The Pizza Box NY brings a diverse pizza lineup to Greenwich Village, New York, NY, with creative pies ranging from classic red sauce to inventive white pizzas sure to satisfy any appetite.

Standout options include Old School "NY Cheese", Classic Pepperoni, Pepperoni Honey, Pizza Al Pastor, Mushroom Pizza (White), and Pesto Squash Ricotta, each offering a distinct and satisfying flavor combination.

Visit The Pizza Box NY in Greenwich Village, New York, NY to enjoy your favorite pizza in person, or take advantage of dine-in, pickup, and delivery to enjoy every slice your way.

Pizza to Try

Faicco's Sausage

$15.97

Pizza with mozzarella, organic tomatoes, and Faicco's sausage.

“The sausage topping is the best, so is the pepperoni. Stop everything you're doing and go there right now”

GF Old School

$18.64

Deep-dish pizza made with house-made dough in a square format.

“Best gluten free pizza ever and everything is farm to table. The gluten free dough is homemade and not frozen dough, which is really exciting for gluten free. Staff was so nice, and patient!”

GF Pepperoni

$22.60

Deep-dish pizza with house-made dough and cup-and-char pepperoni.

“Great gluten free pepperoni pizza!”

Mushroom Pizza (Red)

$15.97

Red pizza topped with sliced, roasted Portobello mushrooms.

“Went to “Pizza Box” for the first time. Wow!!!! Had mini mushroom pizza with red sauce. 🙌🙌🙌Unbelievably delicious!! Really nice staff. Def going back ! 👍👍👍👍”

Mushroom Pizza (White)

$15.97

White pizza topped with mozzarella and roasted Portobello mushrooms.

“Fabulous pizza and the best staff. I loved the white pie and the honey pepperoni. Highly recommend if you are in the area.”

Peach Pancetta

$16.86

White pizza with peach, jalapeño, and pancetta toppings.

“Max is the best!!!!! Everyone go visit him and have the best pizza and wine!!! The new peach pizza is a must try for summer!!”

Pesto Squash Ricotta

$16.86

White pizza with pesto, squash, and fresh ricotta.

“Pizza was so fresh and the crust was so good. Normally I dont love crust or I need to dip it in something but this was so good. We got the squash pesto ricotta pizza. The staff was so also nice!”

Pizza Al Pastor

$16.86

Mozzarella pizza with pork, pineapple, and cilantro-jalapeño sauce.

“Love this place. Went there for the first time last night and got the Al Pastor pizza!! It was AMAZING!! Michael came to check in on us and was so sweet. Cannot recommend this place enough!”

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular pizza options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Pepperoni Honey — This pizza combines cup-and-char pepperoni with Catskills fermented garlic honey for a sweet, savory finish.
Old School "NY Cheese" — This New York-style pizza uses shredded mozzarella, organic Bianco DiNapoli tomatoes, and dough fermented for 72 hours.
Classic Pepperoni — This pizza features EZZO cup-and-char pepperoni, following the restaurant’s old-school pizza style and traditional format.
GF Pepperoni — This square deep-dish pizza combines house-made dough with cup-and-char pepperoni for a thicker style pie.
Mushroom Pizza (Red) — This pizza features sliced, roasted Portobello mushrooms on a red-sauce base in an old-school style.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for pizza throughout the Greenwich Village, New York area. Order your pizza online for convenient pickup or delivery.